- Ludwig von Mises: Ludwig von Mises (1881-1973) – CHỦ NGHĨA TỰ DO TRUYỀN THỐNG
- John Maynard Keynes: John Maynard Keynes
- Friedrich Hayek: Friedrich Hayek (1899 – 1992)
- Milton Friedman: Milton Friedman là ai?
- Paul Krugman: Paul Krugman, Nobel Kinh tế 2008
- Chicago School: Di sản của một trường phái
- Austria School: Austria School
TUESDAY, APRIL 8, 2014
Modern Schools of Economics: A Family Tree
The picture below is a simplified diagram of the modern schools of economics. One will have to open it in a new window to see it properly.
Economics is a discipline in which there are many different competing economic theories, and most of these theories are not just inconsistent on minor issues, but fundamentally contradictory in terms of their major and most fundamental theories.
It follows as a matter of straightforward logic that many competing theories that contradict one another in fundamental ways cannot all be true, and that a great deal of them – that is, theories that are mutually incompatible – are likely to be wrong.
Modern economics begins with Adam Smith and the Classical School, which had two offshoots: (1) Marxism (which in many ways is a development of the thought of David Ricardo) and (2) neoclassical economics.
Around the 1870s, Classical theory was fundamentally reformulated and changed in the so-called marginalist revolution, the great figures of which were Alfred Marshall (1842–1924), Carl Menger (1840–1921), and Léon Walras (1834–1910).
Walras and Marshall stand out as the founders of two main neoclassical traditions. Austrian economics is an offshoot of the work of Carl Menger.
Both the economics of Marshall and Walras still stands at the heart of modern neoclassical economics, the most important theories of which are listed on the top line, and are as follows:
(1) New Classical economics;
(3) New Institutionalism, and
(4) New Keynesianism.
The alternative neoclassical tradition that stems from Alfred Marshall leads to probably the most important economist of the past 100 hundred years: John Maynard Keynes.
Keynes began his career as a Marshallian neoclassical economist but by the time of his fundamental work the General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money (1936) Keynes had essentially repudiated the neoclassical paradigm (though admittedly not completely).
The German Historical School was a major rival of both Classical and neoclassical economics, and it rise to both English and French offshoots but also fundamentally to the Old (American and European) Institutionalist tradition, which by the early 20th century had come to replace the German Historical School as the fundamental competitor to neoclassical economics.
Of course, one must realise that the Old Institutionalists did not all repudiate the neoclassical tradition, and many of them followed the Marshallian neoclassical tradition (Hodgson 2003: 463). Despite this, the Old Institutionalist school had impressive and considerable accomplishments: for example, the early work on administered prices/cost-based prices was done by Gardiner Means, an Old Institutionalist.
Old Institutionalism was a large and influential school in the United States, though not so much in Europe. However, the leading European Old Institutionalists were as follows:
(1) K. William Kapp (1910–1976);
(2) Gunnar Myrdal (1898–1987) and
(3) Karl Polanyi (1886–1964).
A further offshoot of Old Institutionalism was the primitivist/substantivist tradition in ancient economics, the leading figures of which were Karl Polanyi (1886–1964) and Moses I. Finley (1912–1986). Moses Finley wrote a highly influential book on the economies of ancient Greece and Rome called The Ancient Economy(1973; rev. edn. 1999), which rejects many aspects of modern neoclassical economics and is firmly in the Old Institutionalist tradition (although some of Finley’s more extreme views are no longer held even by modern Institutionalists).
Today modern non-neoclassical Institutionalist economics continues to be an alternative to the mainstream neoclassical tradition, but it is thePost Keynesian school that arguably has done most to advance economics in the non-neoclassical tradition of John Maynard Keynes.
Davidson, P. 2005. “The Post Keynesian School,” in B. Snowdon and H. R. Vane (eds.), Modern Macroeconomics: Its Origins, Development and Current State. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham. 451–473.
Finley, Moses I. 1973. The Ancient Economy (updated edn.). University of California Press, Berkeley.
Finley, Moses I. 1999. The Ancient Economy (updated edn.). University of California Press, Berkeley.
Hodgson, Geoffrey M. 2000. “What is the Essence of Institutional Economics?,” Journal of Economic Issues 34.2: 317–329.
Hodgson, Geoffrey M. 2001. How Economics Forgot History: The Problem of Historical Specificity in Social Science. Routledge, London and New York.
Hodgson, Geoffrey M. 2003. “Postwar Heterodox Economics: Institutional Economics,” in Warren J. Samuels, (ed.). A Companion to the History of Economic Thought. Blackwell, Malden, MA. 462–470.
Samuels, Warren J. (ed.). 2003. A Companion to the History of Economic Thought. Blackwell, Malden, MA.
- Debunking Austrian Economics 101 (Updated)
- Debunking Marxism 101 (Updated)
- Post Keynesian Economics 101
- Post Keynesian Price Theory 101
- The Nature, Origin and History of Money 101
- 19th Century Economic History
- Debunking Foucault’s Philosophy 101
- Analytic Philosophy 101
- Mark-up Pricing in 21 Nations and the Eurozone: the Empirical Evidence
- Sources and Data for US Economic History under the Gold Standard
- Probability Theory 101
- Keynesian Uncertainty 101
- The US Recession of 1920–1921
- A Bibliography on Logic and Reasoning
- Say’s Law: History and Critique
- The Natural Rate of Interest: A History and Critiq…
- Why Marx’s Labour Theory of Value is Wrong (in a Nutshell)
- ▼ 2014 (338)
- ▼ April (23)
- Mark Blaug was Right on Mises’ Method
- German Wholesale Price Index 1918–1922
- The Weimar Budget Deficits from 1919 to 1921 and H…
- Academic Journals for Post Keynesian Economics
- Mark-up Pricing in Luxembourg
- Joan Robinson on the Weimar Hyperinflation
- Bob Murphy on 1970s Inflation
- The English Language, Pedantry and Libertarianism
- Adam Smith on the Labour Theory of Value
- Mark-up Pricing in Italy
- Did Kalecki Accept the Labour Theory of Value?
- Mises and Empiricism
- Post Keynesian Economics: A Revised Diagram
- A Third Revised Family Tree of Heterodox Economics…
- A Revised Family Tree of Heterodox Economics
- The Marginalist Pricing Controversy Revisited
- Post Keynesian Economics: A Diagram
- Heterodox Economics: A Family Tree
- Modern Schools of Economics: A Family Tree
- Early Christian Communism?
- Keynes’ “Economic Possibilities for our Grandchild…
- Philip Pilkington on the Financial Sector in the G…
- Marc Lavoie on Heterodox and Post Keynesian Econom…
- ▼ April (23)
Filed under: Kiến thức kinh tế |